Acme Pizza Company Inc - Holly Springs

Chicago Deep Dish Pizza

Authentic Chicago-style stuffed pizza made with traditional recipes and high-quality ingredients. Our signature offering that draws customers from across the state.

• Bold tomato sauce with real chunks
• Quality cheese with perfect pull
• Traditional stuffed pizza style

Gourmet Burgers

Hand-crafted burgers including specialty options like the popular Western BBQ burger. Made with fresh ingredients and served with attention to detail.

• Western BBQ burger is customer favorite
• Fresh, quality ingredients
• Generous portion sizes

Appetizers & Sides

Creative appetizers including their unique take on garlic knots and other shareable options. Perfect for groups or while waiting for deep dish.

• House-made garlic knots (fried dough style)
• Great for sharing with groups
• Quick service for appetizers

Online Ordering

Convenient online ordering system with accurate timing for pickup. Perfect for planning ahead, especially for deep dish orders.

• 3+ hour advance ordering available
• Accurate pickup time estimates
• Perfect for long-distance customers

“I drove from Fayetteville to pick up a deep dish pizza. My uncle is visiting from San Diego, but is a Chicago native. He asked if there was anywhere to get a deep dish pizza. He hadn't had one in years. I had heard from the "Facebook Foodies" group that this was the best place around for a deep dish. We gave it a try, and were not disappointed! We also ordered online 3 hours ahead and the pizza was ready when we got there for expected pick-up at 3 p.m. We received 3 complimentary drinks to go for the ride back to Fayetteville. We also ordered garlic knots that were delicious! While they were not traditional garlic knots, they were still quite tasty. They were more of fried dough with very little garlic flavor. They were still good though, but I was expecting something different compared to other garlic knots. No negative words for this establishment.”

“This place was great. Had the western BBQ burger and it was awesome! Our server was really cool and on point with the drinks. We were a big group and he was very attentive! I hope to go back and try the deep dish. I would've this time around but I wasn't that hungry.”

“From a Chicago native, the best deep dish pizza I’ve had since I left Chicago 10 years ago! Fantastic crust, Great toppings and glorious Cheese pull! Definitely going back again. Too bad it’s so far from Roxboro, or maybe that’s a good thing because I’d be there three nights a week. And as big as a house. I’m going to recommend it to everyone I can.”

“I recently had an exceptional dining experience at Acme Pizza in Holly Springs, NC, and I can't express enough how wonderful our server, Gwen, made our visit. From the moment we walked in, Gwen's warm and friendly demeanor set the tone for an enjoyable evening. Gwen was not only attentive and knowledgeable about the menu but also went above and beyond to ensure our satisfaction. Her enthusiasm for the restaurant's offerings truly enhanced our dining experience. Throughout our meal, Gwen checked in with us regularly, making sure we had everything we needed. Her professionalism, coupled with a genuine interest in ensuring our dining experience was top-notch, left a lasting positive impression. Acme Pizza itself exceeded expectations; the pizza was delicious, with a perfect crust and high-quality toppings. The cozy atmosphere and excellent service provided by Gwen made this visit memorable. I highly recommend Acme Pizza in Holly Springs, and if you're fortunate enough to have Gwen as your server, you're in for a delightful dining experience.”